How do they make it black or white? Look at the recipes used to signal the announcement of a new Pope, and you’ll find they are essentially making smoke bombs.
There’s something almost poignant in the way the Vatican has had to resort to chemistry to get its archaic method of communicating the papal election results to work properly: science helping to sustain a tradition from a distant age. Before this week, “fumata nera” and “fumata bianca” meant little to most people outside Italy. But now all eyes are on the copper chimney of the Sistine Chapel, from which the release of black smoke signals that the 115 cardinals voting to choose the new pope have not yet reached the two-thirds majority needed to secure a decision. When they do, the smoke will turn white. Titanium Hydride Potassium Perchlorate
The smoke comes partly from the burning of ballot papers in a special stove in the chapel. But to colour it white or black, this smoke is mixed with that from chemical additives burnt in a second stove. Traditionally the Vatican produced the different colours by burning wet straw for white and tarry pitch for black.
Anyone who has ever made a bonfire knows that damp grass will work for the former; the less responsible of you will know that chucking old tyres or roofing felt into the flames will turn the smoke black – and what’s more, noxious, because it is then full of sooty carbon particles that can clog the lungs and are potentially carcinogenic.
It’s not concern for the environment that has led the Vatican to change its ways, however. Rather, the smoke in some previous elections came out an ambiguous grey, prompting the decision for the last conclave in 2005 to use a more reliable method based on chemical ingredients.
The Vatican has now revealed what these are. For black, it uses a mixture of potassium perchlorate, anthracene and sulphur; white comes from potassium chlorate, lactose and the conifer resin called rosin, which is often rubbed on violin bows to increase friction.
We needn’t imagine a team of Vatican chemists labouring like alchemists to devise these magic recipes, because what they really show is that the Vatican is making plain old smoke bombs. A smoke bomb – as well as fireworks designed to be particularly smoky – works by combining an easily burnt, carbon-rich compound such as sugar with a so-called oxidizing agent, which provides the oxygen for the combustion reaction. Potassium perchlorate and chlorate (which differ only in precisely how much oxygen they contain) are the most common oxidizers in these applications. Anthracene, lactose (milk sugar) and rosin are the sources of carbon.
Anthracene, found in coal tar, is particularly good for producing big black sooty particles, although it is no longer used in pyrotechnic displays because it is carcinogenic. Sulphur also burns well, and was a traditional component of gunpowder: indeed, the Vatican’s "fumata nera" mix is basically that, with the traditional oxidizer of saltpetre replaced by potassium perchlorate.
White smoke for pyrotechnics is more commonly – and reliably – made by burning zinc dust with the organic solvent hexachloroethane and zinc oxide added. It is widely used for military training exercises. But the solvent is poisonous, and the smoke itself can cause liver damage and respiratory problems – so it’s no surprise that the Vatican chose a safer recipe.
In any event, the smoke system now leaves little to chance. Electrical heating of the flue, and backup air fans make sure that the smoke will come pumping out, and the process will surely have been tested to ensure that the black smoke doesn’t turn white as its big sooty flakes break up into smaller particles – an effect sometimes seen as bonfire smoke rises.
But perhaps the Vatican is missing a trick by being unimaginatively monotone. Why stop at a mere two-colour signalling system? The lurid rainbow smokes used in aerial displays like those of the Red Arrows are simply tinted with bright pigments and dyes such as indigo and rhodamine. Couldn’t we have beige smoke to denote a coffee break, amber to signal an impending decision, and burgundy to show that they're celebrating it afterwards?
If you would like to comment on this article or anything else you have seen on Future, head over to our Facebook page or message us on Twitter.
A simple on the go therapy could help ease anxiety, stress and reduce the impact of traumatic memories.
Former Paralympian Steve Brown visits Paris ahead of the 2024 Summer Olympics and Paralympics.
Most of us have a sense of whether we are a lark or an owl, but is it really as black and white as it may seem?
The Dutch are champions of exercising, but also of sitting down. How is that possible, and why is it dangerous?
Two urban explorers' stories of decay tell a tale of a changing American cultural landscape.
At Icca, Japanese sushi master chef Kazushige Suzuki blends ancient methods with other cuisines.
Filmmaker Gary Hustwit has created a documentary which can rewrite itself before every screening.
On the 80th anniversary of D-Day, veterans who were on the beaches of Normandy recount that fateful day.
The Sisters of the Valley are a group of women defying narco traffickers and tradition at the same time.
Some simple tricks that could have a positive effect on your memory.
Billions of people rely on a cup of coffee to get them through the day. But what does it do to the human body?
There's a lot of hype around magnesium and its ability to alleviate anxiety and depression.
TikTok trainspotter Francis Bourgeois travels through the UK using only British trains.
Aeroplanes have become bigger and faster but their impact on the climate has also increased.
The floating houses built to withstand typhoons and flooding in the Philippines.
Research shows that women rate the quality of their sleep lower than men's.
Marc Cieslak spends a night on ice, camping under the stars.
The reason behind the Red Planet's nickname is also why its sunrises and sunsets look pale blue.
With its own currency and 'head of state', this American micronation has become an odd tourist destination.
Messi has been a big star on the red carpet, eclipsing Meryl Streep. But who will win the Palm Dog this year?
Zombies have a habit of coming back – as witnessed with the premiere of The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live, a new spinoff series. They tap into trauma in US history.
In an era where many films and albums are stored in the cloud, "streaming anxiety" is making people buy more DVDs, records – and even cassette tapes.
The spin-off series Blood of My Blood is due to be filmed in the city's west end in January.
US actress talks about the need to create better spaces for women of colour, as well as her experience growing up in a family of immigrants.
Even if you've never seen a Shakespeare play, you'll have used one of his words or phrases. Hephzibah Anderson explains his genius – and enduring influence.
Aluminium And Potassium Perchlorate Copyright 2024 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.